Denis Defreyne

Weeknotes 2026 W43: How to run an exercise

October 19​–​25, 2026

Quick bits

  • 4

  • PHP, despite all its flaws, remains something I’ll gladly use. I even recently updated my contact form with some additional spam protection!

  • The web feed for my week­notes now has an XSL stylesheet, so that it no longer renders as raw XML. It always felt jarring to link to an XML file with no style. The stylesheet now shows a bit of information about what to actually do with that file.

    Sadly, XSLT support is being removed from browsers, so this might not last for much longer.

  • I added convert-to-WebP and resize filters to my web site a few weeks ago, but now almost 80% of compilation time is spent in image handling (if I don’t do an incremental compilation). It’d probably be smarter to fix the source images instead.

  • I wonder whether my synaesthesia is one of the reasons why my DDID numbering scheme works so well. Digits have colours, and so DDIDs are colourful, too.

  • In Germany, the parcel service DPD is one of the worst. I’ve had nothing but trouble with them. And apparently it is not better in the United Kingdom: the first time I’m using DPD here, and they lost my parcel.

  • One tooth fixed. Two more to go. This is turning out to be an expensive end of the year.1

  • The organic-trash bins have arrived.2

  • It is beyond me why people with giant suitcases refuse to let people off the train first, and then sort of just push people back in. Literally nobody wins.

  • R—— pointed out to me that the reason why iOS 27 looks so ugly is because I have “show borders” turned on in accessibility settings.

Closing off the quick bits with an adorable little diorama that I found on Maps:

A screenshot of Apple Maps: a high-angle view of a road cutting through a heath. Three vehicles are on the road: a tow truck, a blue racecar right behind it, and a roadside assistance vehicle behind that.

This week’s projects

I am moving!

Some excellent news: I have found a flat, and I am moving in November.

I had a streak of good luck recently: I received three offers in total over the course of just a week. For the first one, the property agent put considerable pressure on me (I had a deadline of six hours to pay the holding deposit!), which felt dodgy so I backed out. The second was a bit too far away (though with lake view). The third hit the sweet spot, so I’ll be moving to south-east London soon.

I’m happy to finally have reached the stage where I know what I want, and I’m able to get viewings for the places that are genuinely good opportunities.4

I cannot wait to move.

How to run an exercise

There’s something that I’ve seen in some acting courses that bothers me: exercises where teachers don’t enforce the constraints or success criteria.

Take, for example, the concept of contentless scenes.5 The writing of these scenes is deliberately devoid of meaning. Here’s a random one to illustrate:

A: Did you do it?
B: I tried.
A: You should have asked.
B: Really?
A: Sure.

Such a scene can nonetheless gain meaning, and they are great exercise material for exploring subtext, objectives, and so on. The same scene can function perfectly in the context of a mother/son conversation, and just as perfectly for two criminals attempting to blackmail one another.

But when a student goes off-script during a contentless scene exercise and improvises the text, then the goal of this particular exercise isn’t met. The purpose of the exercise is to express something that intentionally isn’t in the text. That is far from easy (especially early on in training), but the exercise exists to strengthen that muscle; to prevent students from taking the easy way out.

If you want to run five kilometres, you can’t take your car and drive that distance and then call it a success.

As I see it, there are two parts to running an exercise:

  • Constraints (would fail the exercise if unmet). For the aforementioned contentless scene exercise, changing the text would fail the exercise.

  • Success criteria. These are much harder to meet than the constraints. For the aforementioned contentless scene exercise, an exercise would be a success if, for example, the audience can deduce the relationship between the students doing the exercise — certainly not a trivial feat!

Students are not at fault here, to be clear! I myself have messed up plenty of exercises, for many reasons including misinterpreting instructions (and on more than one occasion — I’ll admit — not listening to them). But it falls to the teacher to ensure the constraints are upheld, and to guide the exercise to success. There’s no skill acquisition from improperly executed exercises.6

Why do some teachers not enforce constraints? I’m not sure! Perhaps some teachers want to avoid offending or alienating students? But this certainly does not happen with all teachers.

What would I do differently? This is something that I am thinking about, in part because I’m toying with the idea of setting up my own acting course. There are two parts to how I’d run exercises: make the constraints clear beforehand,7 and ask for a re-run if the constraints are broken.8

It goes without saying that any feedback for students, no matter the form, needs to be given with full respect. That can absolutely be done; even difficult feedback can be given that way.

I see the role of a teacher to continuously take students to the next breakthrough. Running exercises correctly, then, is unavoidably part of that.

This ties in to my desire for fidelity.

Tech links:


  1. Are we already in the “end of the year” time period? Maybe it’s a bit early for that. ↩︎

  2. The hyphen here is important: they are bins for organic trash, not trash bins that are organic. But you knew that already. ↩︎

  3. Foreshadowing. ↩︎

  4. That said, I did get tricked into doing a viewing of a flat that looked utterly different from the photos on the listing. On closer inspection, it turned out the images were AI-generated. Infuriating. ↩︎

  5. Related concepts: “open scene” and “A/B scene.” ↩︎

  6. It in particular bothers me when teachers say “great job” no matter how well-executed an exercise is. Imagine a piano teacher watching a student do their scales, playing the wrong notes and getting the finger position all wonky and still getting a “great job.” ↩︎

  7. As for success criteria: maybe! It depends on the exercise whether or not those need to be clear. I imagine that it can be helpful in certain situations to withhold them. ↩︎

  8. There is also side coaching — giving terse instructions like “use the text!” or “the bus leaves in 30 seconds!” as a scene is in progress — but I don’t think I have the skill to do that effectively just yet. ↩︎

You can reply to this weeknotes entry by email. I’d love to hear your thoughts!
If you like what I write, stick your email address below and subscribe. I send out my weeknotes every Sunday morning. Alternatively, subscribe to the web feed.